Comment, Opinion, Sport

“Rugby League’s Million Pound Game is a danger to mental health and must be scrapped” – Thomas Brady

Off 61

By Thomas Brady


Catalans Dragons triumphed in the Million Pound Game this Saturday, as a result they survived relegation and sent Leigh Centurions crashing back down to the National League after just a single season in the Super League.

While the concept is highly marketable and an exciting situation on paper (a one-game shoot out to see who stays up) this season’s Million Pound Game should be the last.

Many players and fellow Rugby League figures have taken a negative stance towards this weekend’s massive contest. Immediately following the game on the Sky Sports live broadcast, Catalan captain Sam Moa condemned the idea.

“This isn’t a concept that we enjoy to play in as players,” stated Moa, who also offered his condolences to the dejected Leigh side as many of the players’ contracts will now be up in the air. Not exactly the reaction one would expect from a player who’s side had just secured their Super League status.

Resting the pressure of players’ livelihoods, mortgage payments and jobs on a single 80 minute match is an absurd, dangerous and irresponsible action from the RFL. How can anyone be expected to perform at their best under such circumstances?

To put it simply, this cannot continue.

Photograph: Sky Sports

Tears from both sides

There is absolutely zero joy in watching somebody emotionally break down on national television.

Micky Higham gave the most upsetting interview I have ever seen in the sport following his side’s defeat. In a river of tears and understandably unable to compose himself, he said: “I can’t put it into words and feel like I’ve let everybody down.”

On the flip side, there were also tears from the French side’s players. “There’s lots of tears in the dressing room,” revealed coach Steve McNamara, who added they were tears of relief due to the huge amount of tension and pressure surrounding the contest.

Clearly this has far more impact than a simple case of surviving relegation and can cause a great deal of emotional stress on both players and coaches alike.

A game that reduces both teams to tears is uncomfortable at best; and such tension may have been a factor as to why Leigh crumbled in the second half. They made multiple errors, gave away penalties and seemingly could not get their heads back into the game.

Photograph: Sky Sports

State of Mind

Rugby League’s ‘State of Mind’ programme was introduced in 2011 following the shocking suicide of retired Great Britain international, Terry Newton.

The programme was introduced with the aim of improving the mental health of Rugby League players and ensure the wellbeing of anyone in the Rugby League community. The tagline on the rugby-league.com webpage for State of Mind reads: ‘Working to improve the mental health, wellbeing and working life of our rugby league players and communities”. A bit hypocritical don’t you think?

Leigh head coach Neil Jukes addressed this on Saturday too, commenting: “This is hypocritical of what we stand for.” When asked would he like the concept to be scrapped Jukes responded, “100%.”

Likewise, Ben Cockayne talked about the game before his Hull KR side were relegated against Salford in 2016. He rightly spoke out against the match, stating that it was “dangerous” to mental health as it could leave some players with the massive stress of not having a job come the Sunday morning.

How can the RFL stand by and watch these professionals fear their entire lives may be completely changed for the worst, based on a single 80-minute performance, while claiming to be helping to improve players’ mental health?! It’s a disgrace, a shambles, and has been going on for too long already.

The numbers

The biggest of killer of men under 45, is men under 45. Suicide at this age for males is not a main cause of death, it is the single most common cause of death in this category.

5,668 suicides were reported in Great Britain in 2016, and of this number 76% were males. However, 1 in 8 males have a reported common mental disorder, whilst 1 in 5 women have a reported CMD. These statistics are unacceptable.

It is time to start talking about mental health in order to ensure that our peers aren’t suffering in silence and instead get the help and support they deserve.

The Million Pound Game clearly has a negative impact on the mental wellbeing of the players and coaches involved, as expressed on Saturday. The State of Mind programme means nothing if the RFL put more stress and pressure on players than they have ever experienced before; and ultimately, nobody wants to see another Rugby League player contribute to the statistics effecting men under 45.

Game promotion and viewership is a minuscule price to pay to be sure that professionals do not have the ridiculous and harmful stress applied to them from this single, life-changing match.

We’ve seen three years of this game and, whilst it has produced some good moments from a viewer perspective, three years have already been too much. Coaches and players do not enjoy the atmosphere of the concept and the potential ramifications are not worth the risk.

Now it is up to the Rugby League players, coaches, referees, owners and even fans to take a stand against the game and protect the mental health of those involved, before it becomes too late.

About the author / 

Humanity Hallows
Humanity Hallows

Humanity Hallows is Manchester Metropolitan University's official student magazine.

More News Stories:

  • Kourtney Kardashian announces collab with Manchester-born brand

    By Rebecca Monaghan Social media went into meltdown this morning as a PrettyLittleThing X Kourtney Kardashian collaboration was announced. The Manchester-born brand revealed to their 2.1million Instagram followers: “ANNOUNCEMENT. PrettyLittleThing by Kourtney Kardashian is coming. 26.10.17” – creating a flood of comments and tweets. ⚠️ANNOUNCEMENT⚠️ PrettyLittleThing by Kourtney Kardashian is coming 📸 26.10.17.⚡️ @kourtneykardash #PLTbyKourtney pic.twitter.com/4Mo6AGOwfm…

  • Michael Fassbender in The Snowman

    The Snowman review: “Safe to say it won’t last the winter”

    ★★☆☆☆ By Robert Milarvie The Snowman Director: Tomas Alfredson The Snowman promised so much – an A-list cast of Michael Fassbender (Shame), Rebecca Ferguson (The Girl on the Train) and J.K Simmons (Whiplash) within a ridiculous murder mystery plot. While the trailer presented an edgy return for the director responsible for excellent films such as Let The…

  • Preview: Lets Talk About Sex: 30 years of community activism in Greater Manchester

    By Grace Atkinson We have come a long way since the AIDS crisis of the 1980s, yet sexual health remains an integral part of the Manchester community. The stigma attached to sexual health means that not enough people talk about it, or have the right information to ensure safe sex. On Thursday 19th October, in…

  • 5 things I learnt at the Conservative Party Fringe meetings

    By David Keyworth Photography: Nguyen Bui Vu When I heard that the Conservative Party Conference was coming to Manchester Central, I felt a bit like a life-long vegan, told that McDonalds was holding a burger festival in Whitworth Park. Having previously done freelance reporting at the Labour Party Conference fringe, I was offered the same work…

Instagram Feed

1
Something is wrong. Response takes too long or there is JS error. Press Ctrl+Shift+J or Cmd+Shift+J on a Mac.

Categories